OSDev.org

Hello,

Well this kind of question might have already been asked, but I don't know how to formulate it so I make a new forum post (please don't blame me )

So I'm following this tutorial, I'm currently at part 3.6.4 where we are reading values from the disk.

So I compile the code using NASM 0.98.35 (I don't know if that's an old version and if I should update), using the command and when I run it using , it says "Disk read error".

Though when I create a larger disk image using these commands: and then open the floppy through qemu, there is no error anymore, though it displays 0x0000 twice so I think this is linked to the fact the floppy is filled with zeros.

The Hello, world example works so I don't know what's the cause. It feels as if the last two lines were not being compiled (and indeed if I hexdump the the boot_sect.bin file, I don't see the 0xdada and 0xface bytes, the program ends with the magic number 0xaa55)

Any idea what I might be doing wrong?

(I also attached my source code if you don't want to check the tutorial, or if you notice any difference I didn't, because I'm a bit blind sometimes )

EDIT: forgot to mention that I'm pretty much a beginner to OS creation, and not very advanced in ASM either
EDIT 2: well I changed my code just a little (updated the attached files too) so now hexdump says the file ends like this: But it still doesn't work
And I also don't understand why it didn't put the dada and face bytes at the end when the only thing I removed from the code was a line containing ``HELLO_MSG: db 'Booting OS...', 0`` before the ``BOOT_DRIVE: db 0``

Cyxo wrote:So I'm following this tutorial,

Most tutorials are full of mistakes, since the authors of such tutorials are usually also beginners at OS development.

The biggest mistake I see is that the author makes no mention of segment registers. Every memory access involves one of the segment registers, and their initial value is undefined. The author seems to assume that they'll all be zero. Before you can use a segment register to access memory, you must set it.

Well, when I set them all to 0 it doesn't work.
When I try to set them to a higher address (e.g 0x8000 as this is supposed to be were the pile is?), I indeed have no error anymore, though it doesn't even print anything... I've done some research on osdev wiki but I still have no idea what values to set them to

Do you have any guide on that?

The lack of 0xdada and 0xface values might be due to the default block size on your dd command when writing to the floppy disk: it's defualt is 512, so when writing to it, you will only write 512 bytes using count=1.

Edit:

Also, sector count starts at sector 0, not 1.

Oh well thanx, indeed the 0xdada and 0xface were not in the floppy disk, I didn't check that. So it worked when I copied 3 instead of 1 it worked. And I assume it says "disk read error" when I do ``qemu boot_sect.bin`` because there is no actual disk, right?

Also I think he didn't set the segment registers because we were in 16 bits real mode. But in the next chapter we enter 32 bits protected mode and there he sets the segment registers.

Oh well thanx, indeed the 0xdada and 0xface were not in the floppy disk, I didn't check that. So it worked when I copied 3 instead of 1 it worked. And I assume it says "disk read error" when I do ``qemu boot_sect.bin`` because there is no actual disk, right?

If you only load a 1 sector sized file into QEMU, it will only register as 1 sector.
If you try to read any sectors after that first sector, there isn't any, so your code will jump to the error message as the disk is only 1 sector in emulated size.

Yeah I understand that. Thank you very much for your help