Page 1 of 1
Basic paging not working
Posted: Fri Sep 01, 2006 3:47 am
by CyberP1708
Hello,
I am trying to implement paging in my o/s
First I have simply copy - pasted the code taken from
this tutorial and it was working
My idea now was to map virtual memory exactly as physical memory (identity mapping or something like that)
Here are some definitions:
Code: Select all
typedef unsigned int pageEntry;
pageEntry pageDirectory[1024];
pageEntry* pageTable = (void*)0x200000;
And here is the initialisation code:
Code: Select all
printf("Initialisating page directory... ");
for (i = 0; i < 1024; ++i) {
pageDirectory[i] = (unsigned int)(pageTable + i * 1024 * sizeof(pageEntry)) | 3; // each entry points to another page table
}
printf("ok\r");
printf("Initialisating page tables... ");
for (i = 0; i < 1024 * 1024; ++i) { // we write every page tables at once
pageTable[i] = (i << 12) | 3; // each entry to another page
}
asm("mov %%eax, %%cr3" : : "a"(pageDirectory));
printf("ok\r");
I just wanted a page directory linking to every page tables which occupy a contigunous space of 4 MB.
Each page has the flags "read/write" and "present" (set by the "| 3").
But as soon as I enable paging the kernel crashes and BOCHS tells me that it crashed because of "page not present".
As the page fault exception handler is also on a "page not present", the whole computer crashes.
Re:Basic paging not working
Posted: Fri Sep 01, 2006 5:19 am
by Pype.Clicker
beware of constructs such as
Code: Select all
pageTable + i * 1024 * sizeof(pageEntry)
"pageTable + 1" takes you one pageEntry further than the address in pageTable, not 1 byte further ... this may explain that...
Re:Basic paging not working
Posted: Fri Sep 01, 2006 5:21 am
by Kemp
I notice there have been a lot of problems related to not understanding incrementing pointers recently. Maybe this should be added to one of our "read first" threads or faq entries?
Re:Basic paging not working
Posted: Fri Sep 01, 2006 6:20 am
by matthias
Did you enable the PE bit in cr0? Because I don't see it in your code
If you want to I can provide you some sample code that does what you want.
Re:Basic paging not working
Posted: Fri Sep 01, 2006 8:57 am
by CyberP1708
Thanks for your answers
beware of constructs such as
Code:
pageTable + i * 1024 * sizeof(pageEntry)
"pageTable + 1" takes you one pageEntry further than the address in pageTable, not 1 byte further ... this may explain that...
Thank you, it was an inattention mistake but.... still now working
I replaced the line with:
Code: Select all
pageDirectory[i] = (unsigned int)(((unsigned int)pageTable) + i * 1024 * sizeof(pageEntry)) | 3;
Did you enable the PE bit in cr0? Because I don't see it in your code
Yes I have enabled it :-/
These lines are at the end of the ISR of IRQ0 (for multithreading):
Code: Select all
mov eax, cr0
or eax, 0x80000000
mov cr0, eax
If I disable these lines, everything works perfectly
If I replace the last lines of the main code (the code I pasted in the first post) with this...
Code: Select all
...
asm("mov %%eax, %%cr3" : : "a"(pageDirectory));
asm("mov %cr0, %eax; or 0x80000000, %eax; mov %eax, %cr0");
printf("ok\r");
while(1) asm("hlt");
...it doesn't work either (as it probably crashes either in reading the next instruction or writing to 0xB8something in the printf function)
Re:Basic paging not working
Posted: Fri Sep 01, 2006 9:39 am
by Pype.Clicker
well, i'd suggest you set a breakpoint in bochs just after your "mov cr3, eax", and dump physical memory at your page tables and page directory to make sure everything is in place ...
oh, just a thought: make sure your page directory is aligned on a page boundary, too. If you load CR3 with 0x12345678, the cpu will blissfully ignore the "678" part and consider your pdir starts at 0x12345000
Re:Basic paging not working
Posted: Fri Sep 01, 2006 9:43 am
by CyberP1708
Code: Select all
oh, just a thought: make sure your page directory is aligned on a page boundary, too. If you load CR3 with 0x12345678, the cpu will blissfully ignore the "678" part and consider your pdir starts at 0x12345000
Thank you, that was the problem
I have written the page directory on a page boundary and it is now working
I thought that as CR3 can contain 32 bits, it would not ignore the 12 last ones
Re:Basic paging not working
Posted: Sat Sep 02, 2006 2:04 am
by Pype.Clicker
CyberP1708 wrote:
I thought that as CR3 can contain 32 bits, it would not ignore the 12 last ones
The ways of Intel are sometimes obscure to the mere mortals, aren't they? I think the Holy Manuals are pretty clear on this one, though ;D